aaru-dps/Aaru-aaru-dps
1
0
Fork 0
mirror of https://github.com/aaru-dps/Aaru.git synced 2026-02-04 00:54:33 +00:00
Code Issues 657 Packages Projects Releases 19 Wiki Activity

Specific CDDA doesn't dump on non-Plextor drives #485

New Issue
Closed
opened 2026-01-29 15:20:11 +00:00 by claunia · 1 comment
claunia commented 2026-01-29 15:20:11 +00:00
Owner
Copy Link

Originally created by @FakeShemp on GitHub (Sep 9, 2020).

Prerequisites

  • Are you running the latest version?
  • Can you reproduce the problem in the debug version?

Check and fill as appropriate:

  • I was running Aaru under Linux [Ubuntu 20.04]...
  • ...using .NET Core [3.1]...
  • ...in 64-bit

Description

When dumping a specific CDDA with a Plextor drive, the disc dumps fine. But with my non-Plextor drives, this disc results in Cannot read from disc, not continuing....

Exact command line used:

sudo ./aaru --debug m dump -p 25 --first-pregap --persistent /dev/sr0 Bananrepubliken.aaruf

Expected behavior:

The disc to dump

Actual behavior:

Cannot read from disc, not continuing...

If command was expected to work with a device fill this out:

  • Manufacturer: Optiarc, TSSH, Asus etc.
  • Model: TS-H353, BW-16D1HT etc.
  • Bus:
    • USB

Output of command execution with debug output enabled

aaru 5.1.99.3216+b3c57807 built by rebecca-H67MA-UD2H-B3 in Debug
Copyright © 2011-2020 Natalia Portillo

DEBUG (Dump-Media command): --cicm-xml=
DEBUG (Dump-Media command): --debug=True
DEBUG (Dump-Media command): --device=/dev/sr0
DEBUG (Dump-Media command): --encoding=
DEBUG (Dump-Media command): --first-pregap=True
DEBUG (Dump-Media command): --fix-offset=True
DEBUG (Dump-Media command): --force=False
DEBUG (Dump-Media command): --format=
DEBUG (Dump-Media command): --metadata=True
DEBUG (Dump-Media command): --options=
DEBUG (Dump-Media command): --output=Bananrepubliken.aaruf
DEBUG (Dump-Media command): --persistent=True
DEBUG (Dump-Media command): --resume=True
DEBUG (Dump-Media command): --retry-passes=25
DEBUG (Dump-Media command): --skip=512
DEBUG (Dump-Media command): --stop-on-error=False
DEBUG (Dump-Media command): --trim=True
DEBUG (Dump-Media command): --verbose=False
DEBUG (Dump-Media command): --subchannel=any
DEBUG (Dump-Media command): --private=False
DEBUG (Dump-Media command): --fix-subchannel-position=True
DEBUG (Dump-Media command): --retry-subchannel=True
DEBUG (Dump-Media command): --fix-subchannel=False
DEBUG (Dump-Media command): --fix-subchannel-crc=False
DEBUG (Dump-Media command): --generate-subchannels=False
DEBUG (Dump-Media command): --skip-cdiready-hole=True
DEBUG (Dump-Media command): --eject=False
DEBUG (Dump-Media command): Parsed options:
DEBUG (SCSI Device): INQUIRY took 1.0784 ms.
DEBUG (ATA Device): IDENTIFY PACKET DEVICE took 2.8825 ms.
DEBUG (SCSI Device): GET CONFIGURATION (Starting Feature Number: 264, Return Type: Single, Sense: False, Last Error: 0) took 1.1349 ms.
Output image format: Aaru Format.
Device not in database, please create a device report and attach it to a Github issue.                         
DEBUG (SCSI Device): TEST UNIT READY took 4 ms.

DEBUG (SCSI Device): GET CONFIGURATION (Starting Feature Number: 0, Return Type: Current, Sense: False, Last Error: 0) took 2.6426 ms.
Checking if drive supports PQ subchannel reading...                                                            
DEBUG (SCSI Device): READ CD (LBA: 0, Block Size: 2368, Transfer Length: 1, Expected Sector Type: AllTypes, DAP: False, Relative Address: False, Sync: True, Headers: AllHeaders, User Data: True, ECC/EDC: True, C2: None, Subchannel: Q16, Sense: True, Last Error: 0) took 680 ms.
Checking if drive supports full raw subchannel reading...                                                      
DEBUG (SCSI Device): READ CD (LBA: 0, Block Size: 2448, Transfer Length: 1, Expected Sector Type: AllTypes, DAP: False, Relative Address: False, Sync: True, Headers: AllHeaders, User Data: True, ECC/EDC: True, C2: None, Subchannel: Raw, Sense: True, Last Error: 0) took 692 ms.
Checking if drive supports reading without subchannel...                                                       
DEBUG (SCSI Device): READ CD (LBA: 0, Block Size: 2352, Transfer Length: 1, Expected Sector Type: AllTypes, DAP: False, Relative Address: False, Sync: True, Headers: AllHeaders, User Data: True, ECC/EDC: True, C2: None, Subchannel: None, Sense: True, Last Error: 0) took 692 ms.
Drive does not support READ CD, trying SCSI READ commands...
Checking if drive supports READ(6)...                                                                          
DEBUG (SCSI Device): READ (6) took 2.1602 ms.
Checking if drive supports READ(10)...                                                                         
DEBUG (SCSI Device): READ (10) took 696 ms.
Checking if drive supports READ(12)...                                                                         
DEBUG (SCSI Device): READ (12) took 692 ms.
Checking if drive supports READ(16)...                                                                         
DEBUG (SCSI Device): READ (16) took 2.2668 ms.
Cannot read from disc, not continuing...
Uploading statistics
Originally created by @FakeShemp on GitHub (Sep 9, 2020). ### Prerequisites * [X] Are you running the latest version? * [X] Can you reproduce the problem in the debug version? ### Check and fill as appropriate: * [X] I was running Aaru under Linux [Ubuntu 20.04]... * [X] ...using .NET Core [3.1]... * [X] ...in 64-bit ### Description When dumping a [specific CDDA](https://www.discogs.com/Petter-Bananrepubliken/release/10609501) with a Plextor drive, the disc dumps fine. But with my non-Plextor drives, this disc results in `Cannot read from disc, not continuing...`. ### Exact command line used: `sudo ./aaru --debug m dump -p 25 --first-pregap --persistent /dev/sr0 Bananrepubliken.aaruf` ### Expected behavior: The disc to dump ### Actual behavior: `Cannot read from disc, not continuing...` ### If command was expected to work with a device fill this out: * **Manufacturer**: Optiarc, TSSH, Asus etc. * **Model**: TS-H353, BW-16D1HT etc. * **Bus**: * [X] USB ### Output of command execution with debug output enabled ``` aaru 5.1.99.3216+b3c57807 built by rebecca-H67MA-UD2H-B3 in Debug Copyright © 2011-2020 Natalia Portillo DEBUG (Dump-Media command): --cicm-xml= DEBUG (Dump-Media command): --debug=True DEBUG (Dump-Media command): --device=/dev/sr0 DEBUG (Dump-Media command): --encoding= DEBUG (Dump-Media command): --first-pregap=True DEBUG (Dump-Media command): --fix-offset=True DEBUG (Dump-Media command): --force=False DEBUG (Dump-Media command): --format= DEBUG (Dump-Media command): --metadata=True DEBUG (Dump-Media command): --options= DEBUG (Dump-Media command): --output=Bananrepubliken.aaruf DEBUG (Dump-Media command): --persistent=True DEBUG (Dump-Media command): --resume=True DEBUG (Dump-Media command): --retry-passes=25 DEBUG (Dump-Media command): --skip=512 DEBUG (Dump-Media command): --stop-on-error=False DEBUG (Dump-Media command): --trim=True DEBUG (Dump-Media command): --verbose=False DEBUG (Dump-Media command): --subchannel=any DEBUG (Dump-Media command): --private=False DEBUG (Dump-Media command): --fix-subchannel-position=True DEBUG (Dump-Media command): --retry-subchannel=True DEBUG (Dump-Media command): --fix-subchannel=False DEBUG (Dump-Media command): --fix-subchannel-crc=False DEBUG (Dump-Media command): --generate-subchannels=False DEBUG (Dump-Media command): --skip-cdiready-hole=True DEBUG (Dump-Media command): --eject=False DEBUG (Dump-Media command): Parsed options: DEBUG (SCSI Device): INQUIRY took 1.0784 ms. DEBUG (ATA Device): IDENTIFY PACKET DEVICE took 2.8825 ms. DEBUG (SCSI Device): GET CONFIGURATION (Starting Feature Number: 264, Return Type: Single, Sense: False, Last Error: 0) took 1.1349 ms. Output image format: Aaru Format. Device not in database, please create a device report and attach it to a Github issue. DEBUG (SCSI Device): TEST UNIT READY took 4 ms. DEBUG (SCSI Device): GET CONFIGURATION (Starting Feature Number: 0, Return Type: Current, Sense: False, Last Error: 0) took 2.6426 ms. Checking if drive supports PQ subchannel reading... DEBUG (SCSI Device): READ CD (LBA: 0, Block Size: 2368, Transfer Length: 1, Expected Sector Type: AllTypes, DAP: False, Relative Address: False, Sync: True, Headers: AllHeaders, User Data: True, ECC/EDC: True, C2: None, Subchannel: Q16, Sense: True, Last Error: 0) took 680 ms. Checking if drive supports full raw subchannel reading... DEBUG (SCSI Device): READ CD (LBA: 0, Block Size: 2448, Transfer Length: 1, Expected Sector Type: AllTypes, DAP: False, Relative Address: False, Sync: True, Headers: AllHeaders, User Data: True, ECC/EDC: True, C2: None, Subchannel: Raw, Sense: True, Last Error: 0) took 692 ms. Checking if drive supports reading without subchannel... DEBUG (SCSI Device): READ CD (LBA: 0, Block Size: 2352, Transfer Length: 1, Expected Sector Type: AllTypes, DAP: False, Relative Address: False, Sync: True, Headers: AllHeaders, User Data: True, ECC/EDC: True, C2: None, Subchannel: None, Sense: True, Last Error: 0) took 692 ms. Drive does not support READ CD, trying SCSI READ commands... Checking if drive supports READ(6)... DEBUG (SCSI Device): READ (6) took 2.1602 ms. Checking if drive supports READ(10)... DEBUG (SCSI Device): READ (10) took 696 ms. Checking if drive supports READ(12)... DEBUG (SCSI Device): READ (12) took 692 ms. Checking if drive supports READ(16)... DEBUG (SCSI Device): READ (16) took 2.2668 ms. Cannot read from disc, not continuing... Uploading statistics ```
claunia commented 2026-01-29 15:20:13 +00:00
Author
Owner
Copy Link

@claunia commented on GitHub (Nov 7, 2020):

Fixed in 3fdf990924

@claunia commented on GitHub (Nov 7, 2020): Fixed in 3fdf990924ef0b6f2f0f17217888665276c51280
Sign in to join this conversation.
No Branch/Tag Specified
Branches Tags
Labels
Clear labels
archive
beginner
bug
bug
dependencies
device
device
dump image format
duplicate
Epic
feature request
filesystem
filter
gui
gui
gui
help wanted
invalid
invalid
media
needs triage
partitioning scheme
pull-request
Mirrored from GitHub Pull Request
 upstream
wontfix
No Label
Milestone
No items
No Milestone
Projects
Clear projects
No project
Assignees
Clear assignees
claunia
No Assignees
1 Participants
Notifications
Due Date
No due date set.
Dependencies

No dependencies set.

Reference: aaru-dps/Aaru-aaru-dps#485
Delete Branch "%!s()"

Deleting a branch is permanent. Although the deleted branch may continue to exist for a short time before it actually gets removed, it CANNOT be undone in most cases. Continue?