diff --git a/SabreTools.DatFiles.Test/ItemDictionaryTests.cs b/SabreTools.DatFiles.Test/ItemDictionaryTests.cs
index e0a87afc..2dcd6532 100644
--- a/SabreTools.DatFiles.Test/ItemDictionaryTests.cs
+++ b/SabreTools.DatFiles.Test/ItemDictionaryTests.cs
@@ -438,7 +438,7 @@ namespace SabreTools.DatFiles.Test
             var dict = new ItemDictionary();
             dict.AddItem(datItem, statsOnly: false);
 
-            dict.RemoveItem("game-1", (Rom)datItem.Clone());
+            dict.RemoveItem("game-1", (Rom)datItem.Clone(), 0);
 
             Assert.Empty(dict.GetItemsForBucket("default"));
             Assert.Empty(dict.GetItemsForBucket("game-1"));
diff --git a/SabreTools.DatFiles/DatFile.Splitting.cs b/SabreTools.DatFiles/DatFile.Splitting.cs
index cd968860..39df2264 100644
--- a/SabreTools.DatFiles/DatFile.Splitting.cs
+++ b/SabreTools.DatFiles/DatFile.Splitting.cs
@@ -1098,10 +1098,17 @@ namespace SabreTools.DatFiles
                 // If the parent exists and has items, we remove the parent items from the current game
                 foreach (DatItem item in parentItems)
                 {
-                    var matchedItems = items.FindAll(i => i.Equals(item));
-                    foreach (var match in matchedItems)
+                    while (true)
                     {
-                        RemoveItem(bucket, match);
+                        // Reset the items list each time an item is removed so the index is accurate
+                        items = GetItemsForBucket(bucket);
+
+                        // Find the next index that matches the item
+                        int index = items.FindIndex(i => i.Equals(item));
+                        if (index < 0)
+                            break;
+
+                        RemoveItem(bucket, items[index], index);
                     }
                 }
 
@@ -1199,13 +1206,20 @@ namespace SabreTools.DatFiles
                 if (parentItems.Count == 0)
                     continue;
 
-                // If the parent exists and has items, we remove the items that are in the parent from the current game
+                // If the parent exists and has items, we remove the parent items from the current game
                 foreach (DatItem item in parentItems)
                 {
-                    var matchedItems = items.FindAll(i => i.Equals(item));
-                    foreach (var match in matchedItems)
+                    while (true)
                     {
-                        RemoveItem(bucket, match);
+                        // Reset the items list each time an item is removed so the index is accurate
+                        items = GetItemsForBucket(bucket);
+
+                        // Find the next index that matches the item
+                        int index = items.FindIndex(i => i.Equals(item));
+                        if (index < 0)
+                            break;
+
+                        RemoveItem(bucket, items[index], index);
                     }
                 }
             }
diff --git a/SabreTools.DatFiles/DatFile.cs b/SabreTools.DatFiles/DatFile.cs
index 3b17deaf..34bb4518 100644
--- a/SabreTools.DatFiles/DatFile.cs
+++ b/SabreTools.DatFiles/DatFile.cs
@@ -303,13 +303,14 @@ namespace SabreTools.DatFiles
         }
 
         /// <summary>
-        /// Remove the first instance of a value from the file dictionary if it exists
+        /// Remove the indexed instance of a value from the file dictionary if it exists
         /// </summary>
         /// <param name="key">Key in the dictionary to remove from</param>
         /// <param name="value">Value to remove from the dictionary</param>
-        public bool RemoveItem(string key, DatItem value)
+        /// <param name="index">Index of the item to be removed</param>
+        public bool RemoveItem(string key, DatItem value, int index)
         {
-            return Items.RemoveItem(key, value);
+            return Items.RemoveItem(key, value, index);
         }
 
         /// <summary>
diff --git a/SabreTools.DatFiles/ItemDictionary.cs b/SabreTools.DatFiles/ItemDictionary.cs
index 4cd32114..e42ed603 100644
--- a/SabreTools.DatFiles/ItemDictionary.cs
+++ b/SabreTools.DatFiles/ItemDictionary.cs
@@ -284,43 +284,7 @@ namespace SabreTools.DatFiles
         }
 
         /// <summary>
-        /// Remove the first instance of a value from the file dictionary if it exists
-        /// </summary>
-        /// <param name="key">Key in the dictionary to remove from</param>
-        /// <param name="value">Value to remove from the dictionary</param>
-        public bool RemoveItem(string key, DatItem value)
-        {
-            // Explicit lock for some weird corner cases
-            lock (key)
-            {
-                // If the key doesn't exist, return
-#if NET40_OR_GREATER || NETCOREAPP
-                if (!_items.TryGetValue(key, out var list) || list == null)
-                    return false;
-#else
-                if (!_items.ContainsKey(key))
-                    return false;
-
-                var list = _items[key];
-                if (list == null)
-                    return false;
-#endif
-
-                // If the value doesn't exist in the key, assume it has been removed
-                int removeIndex = list.FindIndex(i => i.Equals(value));
-                if (removeIndex < 0)
-                    return false;
-
-                // Remove the statistics first
-                DatStatistics.RemoveItemStatistics(value);
-
-                list.RemoveAt(removeIndex);
-                return true;
-            }
-        }
-
-        /// <summary>
-        /// Remove the first instance of a value from the file dictionary if it exists
+        /// Remove the indexed instance of a value from the file dictionary if it exists
         /// </summary>
         /// <param name="key">Key in the dictionary to remove from</param>
         /// <param name="value">Value to remove from the dictionary</param>