diff --git a/src/cascadia/LocalTests_TerminalApp/SettingsTests.cpp b/src/cascadia/LocalTests_TerminalApp/SettingsTests.cpp
index d3f2647bc8..ef0b6919d8 100644
--- a/src/cascadia/LocalTests_TerminalApp/SettingsTests.cpp
+++ b/src/cascadia/LocalTests_TerminalApp/SettingsTests.cpp
@@ -1421,7 +1421,7 @@ namespace TerminalAppLocalTests
             VERIFY_ARE_EQUAL(L"profile0", terminalArgs.Profile());
             VERIFY_IS_NULL(terminalArgs.Elevate());
 
-            const auto termSettingsResult = TerminalSettings::CreateWithNewTerminalArgs(settings, terminalArgs);
+            const auto termSettingsResult = TerminalSettings::CreateWithNewTerminalArgs(settings, settings.WindowSettingsDefaults(), terminalArgs);
             const auto termSettings = termSettingsResult.DefaultSettings();
             VERIFY_ARE_EQUAL(L"cmd.exe", termSettings->Commandline());
             VERIFY_ARE_EQUAL(false, termSettings->Elevate());
@@ -1444,7 +1444,7 @@ namespace TerminalAppLocalTests
             VERIFY_ARE_EQUAL(L"profile1", terminalArgs.Profile());
             VERIFY_IS_NULL(terminalArgs.Elevate());
 
-            const auto termSettingsResult = TerminalSettings::CreateWithNewTerminalArgs(settings, terminalArgs);
+            const auto termSettingsResult = TerminalSettings::CreateWithNewTerminalArgs(settings, settings.WindowSettingsDefaults(), terminalArgs);
             const auto termSettings = termSettingsResult.DefaultSettings();
             VERIFY_ARE_EQUAL(L"pwsh.exe", termSettings->Commandline());
             VERIFY_ARE_EQUAL(true, termSettings->Elevate());
@@ -1467,7 +1467,7 @@ namespace TerminalAppLocalTests
             VERIFY_ARE_EQUAL(L"profile2", terminalArgs.Profile());
             VERIFY_IS_NULL(terminalArgs.Elevate());
 
-            const auto termSettingsResult = TerminalSettings::CreateWithNewTerminalArgs(settings, terminalArgs);
+            const auto termSettingsResult = TerminalSettings::CreateWithNewTerminalArgs(settings, settings.WindowSettingsDefaults(), terminalArgs);
             const auto termSettings = termSettingsResult.DefaultSettings();
             VERIFY_ARE_EQUAL(L"wsl.exe", termSettings->Commandline());
             VERIFY_ARE_EQUAL(false, termSettings->Elevate());
@@ -1492,7 +1492,7 @@ namespace TerminalAppLocalTests
             VERIFY_IS_NOT_NULL(terminalArgs.Elevate());
             VERIFY_IS_FALSE(terminalArgs.Elevate().Value());
 
-            const auto termSettingsResult = TerminalSettings::CreateWithNewTerminalArgs(settings, terminalArgs);
+            const auto termSettingsResult = TerminalSettings::CreateWithNewTerminalArgs(settings, settings.WindowSettingsDefaults(), terminalArgs);
             const auto termSettings = termSettingsResult.DefaultSettings();
             VERIFY_ARE_EQUAL(L"cmd.exe", termSettings->Commandline());
             VERIFY_ARE_EQUAL(false, termSettings->Elevate());
@@ -1516,7 +1516,7 @@ namespace TerminalAppLocalTests
             VERIFY_IS_NOT_NULL(terminalArgs.Elevate());
             VERIFY_IS_FALSE(terminalArgs.Elevate().Value());
 
-            const auto termSettingsResult = TerminalSettings::CreateWithNewTerminalArgs(settings, terminalArgs);
+            const auto termSettingsResult = TerminalSettings::CreateWithNewTerminalArgs(settings, settings.WindowSettingsDefaults(), terminalArgs);
             const auto termSettings = termSettingsResult.DefaultSettings();
             VERIFY_ARE_EQUAL(L"pwsh.exe", termSettings->Commandline());
             VERIFY_ARE_EQUAL(false, termSettings->Elevate());
@@ -1540,7 +1540,7 @@ namespace TerminalAppLocalTests
             VERIFY_IS_NOT_NULL(terminalArgs.Elevate());
             VERIFY_IS_FALSE(terminalArgs.Elevate().Value());
 
-            const auto termSettingsResult = TerminalSettings::CreateWithNewTerminalArgs(settings, terminalArgs);
+            const auto termSettingsResult = TerminalSettings::CreateWithNewTerminalArgs(settings, settings.WindowSettingsDefaults(), terminalArgs);
             const auto termSettings = termSettingsResult.DefaultSettings();
             VERIFY_ARE_EQUAL(L"wsl.exe", termSettings->Commandline());
             VERIFY_ARE_EQUAL(false, termSettings->Elevate());
@@ -1565,7 +1565,7 @@ namespace TerminalAppLocalTests
             VERIFY_IS_NOT_NULL(terminalArgs.Elevate());
             VERIFY_IS_TRUE(terminalArgs.Elevate().Value());
 
-            const auto termSettingsResult = TerminalSettings::CreateWithNewTerminalArgs(settings, terminalArgs);
+            const auto termSettingsResult = TerminalSettings::CreateWithNewTerminalArgs(settings, settings.WindowSettingsDefaults(), terminalArgs);
             const auto termSettings = termSettingsResult.DefaultSettings();
             VERIFY_ARE_EQUAL(L"cmd.exe", termSettings->Commandline());
             VERIFY_ARE_EQUAL(true, termSettings->Elevate());
@@ -1588,7 +1588,7 @@ namespace TerminalAppLocalTests
             VERIFY_IS_NOT_NULL(terminalArgs.Elevate());
             VERIFY_IS_TRUE(terminalArgs.Elevate().Value());
 
-            const auto termSettingsResult = TerminalSettings::CreateWithNewTerminalArgs(settings, terminalArgs);
+            const auto termSettingsResult = TerminalSettings::CreateWithNewTerminalArgs(settings, settings.WindowSettingsDefaults(), terminalArgs);
             const auto termSettings = termSettingsResult.DefaultSettings();
             VERIFY_ARE_EQUAL(L"pwsh.exe", termSettings->Commandline());
             VERIFY_ARE_EQUAL(true, termSettings->Elevate());
@@ -1612,7 +1612,7 @@ namespace TerminalAppLocalTests
             VERIFY_IS_NOT_NULL(terminalArgs.Elevate());
             VERIFY_IS_TRUE(terminalArgs.Elevate().Value());
 
-            const auto termSettingsResult = TerminalSettings::CreateWithNewTerminalArgs(settings, terminalArgs);
+            const auto termSettingsResult = TerminalSettings::CreateWithNewTerminalArgs(settings, settings.WindowSettingsDefaults(), terminalArgs);
             const auto termSettings = termSettingsResult.DefaultSettings();
             VERIFY_ARE_EQUAL(L"wsl.exe", termSettings->Commandline());
             VERIFY_ARE_EQUAL(true, termSettings->Elevate());
diff --git a/src/cascadia/TerminalApp/TerminalPage.cpp b/src/cascadia/TerminalApp/TerminalPage.cpp
index e130807f78..aaaed4c926 100644
--- a/src/cascadia/TerminalApp/TerminalPage.cpp
+++ b/src/cascadia/TerminalApp/TerminalPage.cpp
@@ -467,7 +467,7 @@ namespace winrt::TerminalApp::implementation
         _tabRow.ShowElevationShield(IsRunningElevated() && _currentWindowSettings().ShowAdminShield());
 
         // Apply the ShowWorkspacesButton theme setting.
-        if (const auto theme = _settings.GlobalSettings().CurrentTheme())
+        if (const auto theme = _settings.GlobalSettings().CurrentTheme(_currentWindowSettings()))
         {
             _tabRow.ShowWorkspacesButton(theme.Window() ? theme.Window().ShowWorkspacesButton() : true);
         }
@@ -4130,7 +4130,7 @@ namespace winrt::TerminalApp::implementation
         _tabRow.ShowElevationShield(IsRunningElevated() && _currentWindowSettings().ShowAdminShield());
 
         // Apply the ShowWorkspacesButton theme setting.
-        if (const auto theme = _settings.GlobalSettings().CurrentTheme())
+        if (const auto theme = _settings.GlobalSettings().CurrentTheme(_currentWindowSettings()))
         {
             _tabRow.ShowWorkspacesButton(theme.Window() ? theme.Window().ShowWorkspacesButton() : true);
         }